I am home. I am catching up.
I am grading papers, finishing a book I have to read for review, doing dishes, making chicken soup ( I have a cold). Sweeping. Calling the roofers (again!) Also processing the week in Baltimore/DC.
Mose is chewing on a purple alligator.
But I'm not overly concerned about that. Here is what concerns me:
A few days ago, I read in DC, at the JCC downtown, near Dupont Circle. There, in our nation's capitol, a lively crowd gathered to talk about interfaith marriage. There were many good questions, many wonderful voices. But there was one man...
Who wanted to ask me about the Jewish race.
About the Jewish "race". Which seemed odd, but so do lots of things, so I explained as best I could that while there are genetic factors in the Jewish equation (hence Tay Sachs) the two more common ways of talking about Judaism (which themselves represent diverse populations) are cultural/traditional, and religious/faith-based.
But I admitted to him that the bloodlines are something people do think about, consider. There is, as much as we want to disregard it, a racial piece to this puzzle. Which means there is sometimes a racism.
I answered the man as best I could, and moved on.
Then, after the reading, a woman came up to me. "That man is a Nazi." She said.
A Nazi!?
She explained to me, firmly, that I should never admit that we are a race/ethnicity. She said we are a "peoplehood" and that I need to diffuse men like that, undercut what they say by explaining we are NOT a race.
Hmm.....
Of course, if that man was/is a Nazi, I'm horrified to think that I might have given him any kind of ammo. Sent him back to his Nazi-play-group with the idea that the Jews are just as concerned about racial pollution as the Germans ever were, or some such nonsense. Of course, that isn't true. Because we're smarter than that, better than that.
And it's true... we are not a race. We are a complicated hybrid. We are the result of a race/tribe (Hebraic/Semitic) which has taken on a faith (Judaism) intermarried, moved, spread, evolved. Maybe it makes sense to call it a "peoplehood." I don't know... I'm not sure what that means.
What are we?
We were once a race, and have now become something else. We are Ethiopian, Yemenite, German, Moroccan, Spanish, Italian, Polish, Chinese. We are adopted, converted, and yes... we are Sammy Davis Jr. We are stronger for all of that, and we know it. We celebrate it. A lot.
So that woman was right, in that we are not "a race." But we are not just a religion either, because there are racial/cultural factors. We *are* concerned about intermarriage. We are concerned about the loss of our heritage, in a way that other religions seem not to be, because there is a racial factor. In that we are more like Italians or Irish, afraid of losing our recipes, our literature, our songs... In fact, it wasn't so long ago that Sephardic Jewish families and Ashkenazic Jewish families didn't want their kids to intermarry. So maybe it isn't "a" race. But it's not entirely true to say we don't concern ourselves with race.
And yes, many of us do share genetic material, however far back you have to go to find the source.
So I'm mulling over this now. I'm considering that the "race" piece of this puzzle is rooted in ignorance, in the voices of those who don't realize how diverse a culture we have become. That I should-- as suggested by the nice woman-- address the topic head-on, when I'm asked a question about "race."
But there's something more to it. Because when the nice woman ran up to me, and said, "We are NOT a race. We are a peoplehood..."
She finished the sentence like this:
"Our race is caucasion. Our religion is Judaism."
Which shows that she doesn't really see the picture clearly either. She is reaching for a way to avoid talking about race, but she is reaching the wrong direction I think. And I wonder, if her son were to marry an african-American girl from an AME church, what she would think of that...
So in the end... I am left only with the sense that we are all so clueless when it comes to these matters. We all have some amount of predjudice in us, which is NOT to say hate or aggression, but we all see the lines. Most of us are not Nazis (thank god) or stupid enough to think that our baser instincts are legititmate.
Most of us know, as that woman did the minute the word "caucasian" flew from her lips... that we are flawed and imperfect creatures. And we seek to better ourselves. Most of us, when we catch ourselves sinking into the mire of irrelevent racial distinctions, pull ourselves back up, apologize sheepishly... and try harder next time.
Because we know our job is
TIKKUN OLAM. Our job is to repair the world.
And that, everyone... is what it is to be Jewish. Race, religion, culture aside. That's what it's all about. Tikkun Olam. So get started!
(But I'll be ready next time, Mr. Nazi. I'll be waiting for that word. And I want to say thank you to the woman at the JCC. She wasn't perfect, but she was right nonetheless. She spotted the wicked intentions across the aisle, which I did not see, and she helped me learn something. So now I know what I'll say if it comes up again.
But let's all take a minute to think about this.)