To talk about anti-Semitism...
I don't want to believe
it's happening. At Hillel conferences, everyone wants to talk about the way
it's happening, how
it's happening, the terrible truth of
what's happening... and I've held out, argued...
Because I'm a progressive lefty-gal and I don't want to believe this about my community. But I have to admit,
it's happening. The left is teetering on the edge of something very ugly. The progressive world I love is walking a fine line.
Let's consider what's going on in the region:
Ariel Sharon is a bad man?
Okay, I can dig on that.
Israel is committing attrocities?
Sure, yeah, they kill civilians and that sucks.
Settlements are nasty and illegal?
Yes, I'll buy in...
Israel doesn't deserve to exist?
Whoa! Nope. Hold on. I can't go there with you.
A few weeks ago, in a bar, a nice, progressive, educated, older man asked me what I do for a living.
"What do you do for a living?" he asked.
"I'm a director for Hillel." I replied.
"And what does that mean?" he inquired.
"Well," I said, "basically, I make sure that the Jewish students on campus have a place to go. I help provide a community, activities. I'm like a big Jewish sister. It's nice!"
"Hmmm," he said, shaking his head. "I just don't know how to feel about the Jews right now. You know, with Israel and all. Sorry."
To which I wanted to respond. "Yeah, I understand... I don't know how to feel about white older men right now, with the entire history of the western world and all."
You'll shake your head as you read this... you'll say, "Hey, that's just one stupid asshole in a bar.
But stupid assholes tend to come in waves. They tend to make each other feel okay about their own asshole-ness. And so their voices get louder and louder. And then the non-assholes feel weirder and weirder speaking up and saying, "WOW! You're a total asshole. Shut the fuck up!"
Truly, I'm having a lot of these conversations lately. A lot of them.
There are so many ways to be Jewish, and so many ways to be Israeli. It's a country like any other country, a beautiful troubled place. And the people who live there are doing all sorts of things... demostrating, forming new political parties, setting up aid centers for Palestinians.
When I lived in Haifa I worked for a women's center with Jews, Arab Israelis, Druze, and Palestinians.
Israelis are on your side, whichever side you're on...
You can hate the Likud party, Sharon, the settlements, the wall. You can dislike the idea of forced military service. You can feel uncomfortable with the word "Zionism."
But unless you plan to judge every American, or English speaker, or white person, or man... unless you decide to hate the people of California or South Dakota or New York based on American policies.... then it seems unfair to hate Israel... or Jews because of what has happened in Israel over this last wave of the intifada.
It seems unfair to expect that all Israelis should give up their right to exist because their leadership is shitty.
What neighborhood do
you live in?